Executive Summary
A self-administered mail questionnaire
was used to collect information from Fort Hood fishing license
holders regarding their willingness to pay increased costs to
fish at Fort Hood, demographic characteristics, fishing
participation, attitudes, experience preferences, and opinions
on management tools. The survey was sent to 1,200 Fort Hood
license holders between October 8, 1997 and December 10, 1997. A
total of 545 usable questionnaires were returned. After
non-deliverables were eliminated, the effective response rate
was 58%. A telephone follow-up of non-respondents suggests that
the data over represent anglers who are more actively involved
in fishing. This should be taken into consideration when viewing
and using the results of this survey.
Characteristics of Fort Hood Anglers
| |
Most anglers were Anglo
(68%) and male (84%). |
| |
Most (80%) anglers were
between 20-49 years of age. The mean age was 36.3 years. |
| |
Most (61%) anglers were
military personnel (retired or active). |
| |
Most (69%) anglers had an
average household income less than $40,000. The median
income category was $30,000 to $39,999 |
| |
Fishing Participation
Patterns and Preferences |
| |
Fort Hood anglers had an
average of 21.1 years experience fishing in freshwater. |
| |
Most (92%) anglers had
fished in freshwater during the last year, and 84% had
fished at Fort Hood during that time. |
| |
The average number of
days fished in freshwater in the last year was 37.3
days. The average number of days fished at Fort Hood in
the last year was 24 days. |
| |
Belton Lake (26%) and
Gray Lake (14%) were the most common locations fished at
Fort Hood. |
| |
When fishing at Fort
Hood, 30% of anglers prefer to fish with friends, 25%
prefer to fish alone, 23% prefer to fish with family,
and 19% prefer to fish with family and friends together. |
| |
Black bass was the most
preferred species to catch for 35% of Fort Hood anglers.
Other species most preferred by Fort Hood anglers were
catfish (15%), crappie (5%), and trout (3%). Thirty-five
percent of Fort Hood anglers did not have a preferred
species. |
| |
Overall, 30% of Fort Hood
anglers were very or extremely satisfied, and 26% were
not at all or slightly satisfied with fishing at Fort
Hood. |
Fishing Attitudes and Experience Preferences
| |
Statements about
recreational fishing in freshwater receiving the highest
level of agreement were "I like to fish where there are
several types of fish to catch" (76%), "The more fish I
catch, the happier I am" (75%), and "A fishing trip can
be successful even if no fish are caught" (71%). |
| |
Statements about
recreational fishing in freshwater receiving the lowest
level of agreement were "I want to keep all the fish I
catch" (62%), and "If I thought I wouldn't catch any
fish, I wouldn't go fishing" (51%). |
| |
The most important
reasons for fishing at Fort Hood were "To relax", "For
the fun of catching fish", "To get away from the regular
routine", and "To be outdoors", which were rated as very
or extremely important by 89%, 84%, 82%, and 81% of
anglers, respectively. |
| |
The least important
reasons for fishing at Fort Hood were "To obtain a
trophy fish", "To learn how to fish before I fish
elsewhere", and "To practice my skills before I fish
elsewhere", which were rated as slightly or not at all
important by 69%, 59%, and 52% of anglers, respectively. |
Management Tools
| |
The most preferred tools
for managing Fort Hood fisheries were "Stocking native
freshwater fish in freshwater", "Releasing fish below a
certain length", and "Fishing derbies to teach children
how to fish", which received support or strong support
from 91%, 91%, and 88% of anglers, respectively. |
| |
The least preferred tools
for managing Fort Hood fisheries were "Releasing fish
above a certain length limit", and "Not being allowed to
fish in certain restricted areas", which received
opposition or strong opposition from 33% and 33% of
anglers, respectively. |
Economic Valuation
| |
The probability that a
respondent would agree to pay a higher fee for a Fort
Hood fishing license (the current license cost was $12)
was negatively correlated with license cost, and
positively correlated with satisfaction level with
fishing at Fort Hood. |
| |
If angling quality at
Fort Hood was to remain the same, 72% of anglers would
be willing to pay $14, and 43% of anglers would be
willing to pay $20, for a Fort Hood fishing license.
With no change in angling quality, the license cost at
which 50% of anglers would cease to purchase a Fort Hood
fishing license was estimated to be $18.30. |
| |
If angling quality at
Fort Hood was to decline by 25%, 33% of anglers would be
willing to pay $14, and 19% of anglers would be willing
to pay $20, for a Fort Hood fishing license. With a 25%
decrease in angling quality, the license cost at which
50% of anglers would cease to purchase a Fort Hood
fishing license was estimated to be $6.53. |
| |
If angling quality at
Fort Hood was to increase by 25%, 91% of anglers would
be willing to pay $14, and 68% of anglers would be
willing to pay $20, for a Fort Hood fishing license.
With a 25% increase in angling quality, the license cost
at which 50% of anglers would cease to purchase a Fort
Hood fishing license was estimated to be $23.47. |
Statistically significant differences between military
personnel and civilians
| |
Civilians were an average
of five years older, and had an average of four years
more fishing experience than military personnel. |
| |
Civilians were more
likely to: own a powerboat, agree with the statement "I
usually eat the fish I catch", be more motivated to fish
"to obtain fish for eating", support prohibiting the use
of certain types of sport fishing gear, and fish with
family or family and friends together. |
Discussion
| |
The models generated to
analyze the trade-off between license cost and the
proportion of anglers willing to pay that price should
be a useful tool to managers in support of decision
making efforts at Fort Hood. If license fees are to be
increased without a reduction in the numbers of licenses
sold, there is a need for a concurrent increase in
fishing quality and/or anglers' satisfaction level. |
| |
From survey results it
seems inconsistent that trout and catfish are the
species stocked primarily in post waters while the most
preferred species is black bass. Greater emphasis on
stocking bass could help enhance the satisfaction level
of anglers and increase their willingness to pay
increased license costs. |
| |
If increasing and
maintaining the satisfaction levels of Fort Hood anglers
is of concern, managers must strive to ensure that
anglers achieve a range of non-activity experience
preferences that include being outdoors, relaxing, and
escaping everyday pressures. |
| |
When providing fishing
opportunities at Fort Hood, managers must be sensitive
to differences between military personnel and civilians,
and between Fort Hood anglers and the statewide
population of anglers in general. |
| |
Future studies should pay
attention to the problem of high levels of
non-deliverables in order to minimize problems
associated with non-response bias. |
|
|